robinellen (robinellen) wrote,

  • Mood:

Middling on GoodReads...

After tossing a book aside in disgust last week, I chanced upon a random comment about Good Reads. I've heard things about it before, and I've actually joined and posted a few books with ratings (only 4 or 5 stars, however), but I haven't had the time to write full-on reviews.

I went on and looked up the book I didn't like, just to see what others were saying...and in one sense, it was very educational because a number of the reviewers pointed out correlations between the MC and Bella of Twilight fame. I hadn't noticed that (um, not having read the entire book), but as soon as I saw it mentioned, I immediately agreed. And no wonder I didn't really connect with this book, as it was very similar to Bella in many of the ways which made me put down Twilight, as well.

After looking up that book, I tried a few others I've read...and whoa. There's a ton of vitriol on that site! I'm astonished at how many people not only hate various books, but they also ream the authors. I haven't yet disassociated myself from GoodReads, but I won't be adding any more books. I'm trying to decide if it's even worth it to keep the few I've listed there (with ratings and no reviews) or if I should just pull out completely.

One thing's for sure -- I won't be looking at that site if I ever get published myself. Holy crap! It would be so hard to keep going after reading some of those reviews. Even though there is a mix of positive and negative for just about every book under the sun (which is a good reminder of subjectivity), the negative ones are so extreme.

But I'm curious -- how many published writers find that kind of feedback valuable? And if you're a member of GoodReads, what does it do for you? (I'm trying to decide how to handle my own participation.) As a reader, do you use it? (This was my first time reading through various reviews, and although it was interesting, it did nothing to change my opinions about the books I'd already read...but I could see that it might sway my thoughts if I was waiting to read a book.)
Tags: book talk
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.